What happens after a public scandal? Examining Russell Brand and David Walliams, this article explores restitution and rebuilding trust.
So are you as rational as you believe?
The cases of Russell Brand and David Walliams raise an uncomfortable question that often gets lost in public debate: what should happen after wrongdoing is exposed? Beyond accountability and consequences lies a rarely discussed concept – restitution.
This is part 3 of a series. You will find the other 2 at the end of this article.
Every public scandal follows the same pattern.
Allegations emerge. The public takes sides. Supporters call for forgiveness, critics demand accountability, and the accused apologises, denies wrongdoing, or attempts rehabilitation.
Yet one question is rarely asked:
What is owed to the people who were harmed? Not the public, nor social media but the actual victims. This is the missing conversation about restitution – a topic which I find highly interesting.
Modern culture is obsessed with redemption. We want to know whether someone has changed, whether they deserve a second chance, and whether they should be allowed to rebuild their career or reputation.
But redemption and restitution are not the same thing.
Redemption asks, “Have I changed?”
Restitution asks, “What do I owe?”
One focuses on the individual. The other focuses on those affected by the individual’s actions.
I was looking forward to writing this particular part of the series because RESTITUTION is a topic after my heart. And as a Bible student, I know God is also big on restitution even though the church has chosen silence. The church would rather shame the victim into forgiveness than hold the perpetrator accountable or demand restitution.
And below are three of the commonest examples I cite for what restitution is or not.
“But as they were taking her out to stone her, she sent this message to her father-in-law: “The man who owns these things made me pregnant. Look closely. Whose seal and cord and walking stick are these?” [Genesis 38]
Genesis 38 – the story of Judah and Tamar – tells the best story on restitution. A man denies his widowed daughter-in-law her dues. She plots to get it back. Her plot works. Because traditionally he holds the power of her life in his hands, he reads out the death penalty on her.
However, before she was led off, she surreptitiously called him out without calling him out. Most men, would have gone ahead with the sentencing to save face, but he owned up. And did the right by her ignoring the attendant scandal.
Now, you may have to read up on that story to grasp what fully transpired. But I am sure you are familiar with this other story of Jacob and Esau. You do recall that Jacob ran away after defrauding his brother, right? Can you recall any apology tendered or any feeling of remorse? There was none.
Until Jacob, now a wealthy man with much at stake – families and assets was relocating to his homeland. When his servants told informed him about Esau and his entourage, Jacob panicked and tried to make amends.
Not because he was sorry after all these decades, but so that Esau would spare him. The selfish bachelor who ran away from home was now returning as a husband, father, CEO but still selfish. It was all about him and what he stood to lose. By the way, Jacob was Judah’s father and great to see that the apple fell very far from the tree on this count.
“And Ya’aqob was greatly afraid and distressed. So he divided the people that were with him, and the flocks and herds and camels, into two and said, “If Esaw comes to the one group and strikes it, then the other group which is left shall escape” [Genesis 33]
“Deliver me, I pray, from the hand of my brother, from the hand of Esaw, for I fear him, lest he come and shall strike me and the mother with the children”
Then of course, you must know the wealthy but unscrupulous chief tax collector, Mr Zach. A repentant soul who understood that with redemption comes restitution. And he made the offer without prompting.
“But Zacchaeus stood and said to the Lord, behold, the half of my goods I give to the poor. And if I have defrauded anyone of anything, I restore it fourfold” [Luke 19.8]
Three men. Two understood the pain they had caused and honestly sought to make it good. One was more concerned about himself and not losing everything he had acquired.
That kind of personal responsibility attitude is missing from a Russell Brand who is seeking public forgiveness after his scandal yet downplaying restitution. Minimising the pains of victims is not calling yourself accountable, especially if you claim to be a new creature.
Too often, public debates centre on whether a fallen figure can recover. The people who live with the consequences of the harm become secondary characters in their own story.
This pattern extends far beyond celebrity culture. It appears in politics, business, institutions, and families.
Perhaps restitution is overlooked because it is costly. An apology costs little.
Restitution requires acknowledging that actions create debts: moral, emotional, and relational. Some cannot be fully repaid. Trust may not return. Opportunities may remain lost. Some wounds heal but leave scars.
Accountability is not the enemy of growth. It is its foundation. Without consequences, remorse remains theoretical. Without restitution, redemption can become little more than image management.
None of this means people cannot change. Human beings are capable of genuine transformation. But personal growth does not erase the impact of past actions. Some relationships never recover. Some doors never reopen. That is often not punishment but reality.
The true test of character is not how successfully someone rebuilds a reputation. It is whether they place the needs of those harmed above their desire for restoration. Like both Judah and Mr Zach teaches us.
There is a profound difference between saying, “I want my life back,” and “I want to make things right.”
One asks what the world owes me. The other asks what I owe the world.
When admiration becomes loyalty at all costs, truth suffers and accountability weakens. The lesson is not that we should never admire people, but that we should never place them beyond question.
In the end, restitution is what remains after the headlines fade. It is the quiet work of accepting responsibility, making amends where possible, and recognising that true transformation is measured not by image, but by character.